Choice Home Warranty Reviews

Want to say it was a great service call.. technician was very respectful and knowledgeable. Was even able to fit me in ahead of my schedule appointment.

Absolutely horrible. File the claim online they said, it will be much faster. So I did. Filed a claim online, on July 14th, 2025, early AM to replace/fix garbage disposal. Got email confirmation someone will contact me within 24 to 48 hrs. A week went by, no one contacted me. I called customer service the following Monday, no one had any updates except they were looking for a tech to do the job. And, they said I was put on the priority lists, someone should be contacting me in 24/48hrs...again. 48 hrs. later, no one has contacted me. I called them again. still no updates, they are still calling around looking for a tech to do the job. Now they say, hire your own tech but he has to do a diagnostic report, upload it to the website and then wait for approval. WHAT? how long will that take? Approx. 2 to 3 days, up to a week. So that will put me at least 2 weeks out, minimum, without my disposal. These guys suck!!!

Equipment to fix furniture was mailed to my home with no info to as to what it was for what to do with it. Furniture company was not notified it was mailed to me. When repair man came he only has order to repair one chair when I put in request for two and different times. Time of repair was excessive.

Very disappointed your company. My garage door opener would not work. I sent a claim in with your company. The person comes out and diagnose. The problem. Bearings are going out of my garage door. I need two new sensors. One spring is broke and the other one is about to break. The wire that connects the two sensors got caught in my chain and also broke the company that comes out to fix the garage door notes all of these things cause your company and first choice Home Warranty gives him the go-ahead to replace one spring $685 later. Plus a $75 service fee your company disappointed me and I will not be renewing.

I do not understand the point. I purchased my first home in April. It’s a newer build but still 9 years old so I purchased a warranty. A month after purchase I noticed a soft spot in the floor of our shower…not covered. Recently I noticed a water spot under the shut off in my basement; concrete visibly wet and dripping coming from the pipe above. Files a claim and they sent a plumber out. He comes and takes photos, says warranty should have no issue covering it and he has seen this multiple times. Only thing is they used pex ultra piping in my house; so NOT covered. Waiting to hear back how much this is going to cost me out of pocket. I just don’t understand the point in having this if when things go wrong nothing is covered.

Absolutely ridiculous outcome. Company was willing to pay $1,800 in parts but when a part was back ordered and the supplier said it could be sooner but average time for part is a few months. Choice decided they’d only give me $800 towards a new fridge. Now I don’t understand this at all. It doesn’t make any sense to me. They also told me the check for $800 takes 30 to receive it. It’s already been 3 weeks since it broke!! What’s 4 more?!

I filed my first claim for my air conditioner that was not working. The technician came out and told me the compressor was broken. Then I received an email from the company stating I had to pay $3100 out-of-pocket to repair my air conditioner. When I inquired as to why such a huge amount to have the warranty company, fix my air condition, they stated that items needed to be. replace that we’re not covered under the warranty. I had a conversation with most of the claims adjuster as well as a technician, and I received two different stories from each of them. I do not trust them and I feel like I’m being scammed out of additional monies I would not have to spend otherwise. But now I have no choice, but to deal with this company that could never use again.

When i received an appointment from a company I've never heard of with a phone number from another state, I questioned whether this was a good match for us. When I finally was able to reach a live person, she put me on hold to "look up my account" for 9 1/2 minutes and then hung up without saying another word. This is unacceptable. Amazingly unacceptable.

Website is very user friendly. Easy to submit a claim and check status. Very quick response and service technician came the next day. Professional and speedy repairs. Thanks!

I called today to get someone to look at my dryer. Choice Warranty customer service was very prompt in calling me back. The agent was very helpful and so pleasant to talk to

Worst experience with this company. I was approved for a water heater replacement but they refused to pay for the installation. So I discovered that they will only pay $300 for the installation and will leave the rest to the customer which was $455. Nowhere in the contract does it mention that they will only pay $300 for labor and or installation. They use the term "uncovered cost" and try to blame it on the plumbing company they use. The only other option they gave me was to buy the water heater myself and they would reimburse me after sending in the receipt. However, they only offered me $417 dollars for the water heater which costed over $1500. Stay away from this company!

Agreed to a one year prepaid premium of $613.50 and gave my debit info. Specified the debit was only for one year's premium to be debited. Right after, they offered me the VIP premium offer if I signed up for 6 years. I considered the offer then was informed that the 6 year's coverage was to be prepaid as well. I balked...refusing the offer. They told me my cancellation was accepted. Upon discontinuing the call, I checked my account, the debit for the UNAUTHORIZED amount of $2835.00 had already been removed from my account. Then I get an email detailing the cancellation and that my refund would be returned within 15 to 30 days! Don't deal with them...a combination of used car sales and fly by night solar system companies. And now, at 75 years old, I've been bit by all 3.

This company sale you a dream. My first claim was denied because of a valve that failed in my A/C unit and just so happen that valve is not covered. They keep telling me to read my contract but my contract don't list what valves in your system is not covered. If you say you cover the A/C system why is there exclusions? My system has been shutoff by the people they sent out and now they're telling me to call the repair company and ask for a discount to get it fixed. I have no trust that this company will repair any of my claims. Horrible warranty plan and I am canceling my contract dont care the money I will lose. I'm not giving them anymore of my money.

We liked the speedy scheduling service as well as the successful repairs that were made in a timely manner. We are so glad to be a customer of Choice Home Warranty’s.

They are very unresponsive. I had a refrigerator issue with the filter and ice maker. They told me it wasn't covered because there was a recall. I never got a recall notice. The repairman told me to continually defrost the ice maker on a monthly basis and use pliers to change the water filter. Unacceptable! More recently, dishwasher buttons were not working. They sent a repair man the next day, which was good. Without asking me which was bad. But I called the repair man to come which he did. He told me he would have to file a request for a new button unit from Choice. That's the last I heard about the issue and that was over two weeks ago. I contacted the repairman and told him I had not heard from Choice had he? He said he would look into it in the meantime I have no communication from Choice as to whether they are actually going to cover the replacement of the buttons. This also is unacceptable. I paid a lot of money for this insurance. Their people don't communicate and they are rude. It's not what the salesman told me he was selling me when I bought a three-year contract. I will not sign another contract.

After experiencing 2 claims, the first one denied once plus an appeal (stated it was a pre existing condition which it obviously wasn't. Then a couple months later my dryer was progressively taking longer to dry my clothes (duct cleaning) so I put in a claim and it took 2 weeks and they finally sent an email with a vendor scheduled to come out. I called the vendor as per their ask to confirm and he was great and corrected the issue which was a duct cleaning that was needed. I paid him the $85 service fee and he left. A while later he calls and says that Choice will not pay him, so I ended up calling and getting to a supervisor and they assured me if he called back in that he would get paid. Well he called back in and after getting hung up on by the rep 4 times he got through finally and they argued and said that he was not the correct vendor and they would not pay him. It was a mistake on my part for evn choosing this company and will not recommend them.

The only thing I disagree with them so far is that I had a plumbing issue. Everything was backed up, but according to the agent, the system had not assigned a contractor to my case for almost 15 hours. I was told they didn't know how long the wait would be, and that I could hire my contractor and get reimbursed. I only got reimbursed a little over 1/3rd.

I liked the technician that provided the service. The prior warranty company had "human/live" customer service, and the claim was responded to the same day. and dispatched the following day.

Most of the repair companies that they use are sub-par, some are flat out incompetent. Although I've gotten most covered, it's like pulling teeth. They also replace broken items (if your so lucky to have the claim approved) with the cheapest parts they can get away with. Our first claim was our air conditioner. It was denied, we had to jump through hoops to finally get it covered. Another claim was our under cabinet ice maker. They sent 5 companies out to try and fix it, finally they just paid us for a new one...the problem...they only gave us $400 to buy a new one...the cheapest ones are in the $1500-$1700 range. My final straw was when our heater went out. The company they sent out was completely incompetent. Their diagnosis was a surge caused a blower motor to fail. Surges are not covered. The only problem, I have a whole house surge protector and a surge protector on the unit itself. I had my HVAC company come out to look at the unit. There was no surge, in fact the motor was still spinning, it was the module that controls the motor. When presented with the real diagnosis, they still denied the claim. I would highly recommend another company, although I have heard they are pretty much all the same. If you do plan on going with this company, plan on being with out your system (whatever that may be) for at least a week! With this last claim, I was with out heat for nearly a month before they denied my claim. My first claim was also around a month before I got it fixed. So, if that happens to be your A/C or heat and it's in the middle of summer or winter...

What I liked about my ice maker repair, is the guy was diligent trying to find the leakage issue. He pulled the fridge out to look in the back and found a cracked tubing. He replaced using the material the previous guy left. What I didn't like about this repair, it three attempts to finally get the ice maker fixed.

I liked the service man who reviewed my loss. I disliked how slowly the company responded to my urgent need. I'm 86-years-old. My wife is 93-year-old and needs my help. We need to refrigerate medicines. The company treated my claim for a failed refrigerator with disregard. Be aware... damage caused by power surges are not covered in the service contract!

During our last service call, we were deemed to need a new refrigerator. The refrigerator we had was a nice Kenmore with the icemaker. While they did except the replacement, they only wanted to give us about half of what it cost to buy a new one. And then you have to wait 15 to 30 days to get that. I don’t know about anyone else, but it’s hard to live without a refrigerator. And I thought a home warranty was to help you in these unexpected times. It would be better to save your money in a savings account so that when you need a refrigerator, you can actually buy it and actually replace it. They wanted to give us about enough for a new mini fridge. I will not use them again. And I would never recommend them to anyone.

Unlicensed contractors were sent out to our place for claims, to include one person who showed up in a black spray painted van, their family name spray painted in white on the side, with a busted windshield. Our boiler hasn't worked since September and due to state laws requires a licensed plumber. Lot's of unlicensed companies that can't afford to wait for reimbursement have shown up, all say the thing needs to be replaced. Local companies warn AGAINST doing reimbursement with this company saying that if you go that route they have never heard of a client being reimbursed. Apparently they have settled from what I understand online fraud complaints with several states attorney generals and have several more that they are expected to settle. Also we were told that there is no time limit that they are required to act in and that if our pipes burst due to their inaction for going on four months that they have no liability. As a disabled veteran, I would heavily recommend that you avoid this company, and any real estate company that sells there services. Look at the reviews listed, the good ones are almost solely from dealing with their sales staff, not the service side of their company.

Be very cautious. I renewed, I’m regretting it. This company is giving me the run around behind replacing my A/C unit. As I type this, they literally resend me the same email asking me to approve a service their own technician said would not fix my A/C system, they’re giving me and their technician the run around, he asked for paperwork to be sent so that he could fill out t what was needed to replace the system, he is still waiting. It’s going on a month without my A/C. Also, this company denied my water heater claim and I am still waiting to be assigned a claims specialist because I disputed their reasoning. They claimed they serviced a water heater they never serviced, in fact, they denied the claim under the old contract and I had to pay a company to replace that water heater at my own expense. I’m under a new contract, that water heater they claimed they serviced, is not a topic of discussion because it’s not the water heater I filed a claim on a new contract. They are very shady, oh, and you will more than likely have to pay more than your deductible if they fix or replace anything. As a matter of fact, you will get denied on things and have to hire someone to fix it. Always keep your receipts, they will ask for them if you file a claim again on a system they denied fixing before. Heck, I’m still waiting on them to fix my dispenser for my Ice-maker on my refrigerator, that claim is several months old, they sent the tech the wrong part, and I’m still waiting to hear back from that. Be very cautious. No one should be a victim of faulty business practices and a company willingly trying to get you to cancel the contract so they don’t have to complete their contractual obligations. I’m a disabled vet, and paid my contract in full due to limited resources. I am regretting that decision, don’t be fooled by the people saying it’s such great service. Their rep really sold how they had gotten better since my first contract, it looked promising at first, but then, the same old thing. When it comes to replacing things like I mentioned, be prepared. Be careful, seek wisely.

I was told by my brother in law to get this warranty. Everything was good till my central ac went bad in the middle of July when it was 95-105 in the house with a 2 disabled people, diabetic, 87 y/o elderly who can't walk. That's when you realize not helpful at all. They told me to go get my own company because Blum management who took the job kept canceling. Mom had a fever almost passed out from the heat. Top it we lost electricity so didn't have fan either. I begged CW to get me someone sooner but no one helped me. Every person I spoke to was rude nasty attitude. I tried to get my money back & was giving me practically nothing back. I begged for my mom but they were all heartless. I called several times with no response. I was on disability & just went back to work still sick. At least I got to go to work but my disabled mom couldn't go anywhere. I asked what would they have given if they company their authorize get paid. They said $3000 & still did not give me that. Gave me only yesterday 450 out of 12,000. Only Antiwaque was kind & cared but still couldn't give me the $. Stopped talking to my bro in law because of this when I asked him to help me & he didn't. So upsetting what happened. Been very sick from the non-stop calls to CW with getting rude, nasty resolution specialist such as Danielle. You can never get the same person you spoke to do you have to tell over & over again what happened. Customer service usually all men are rude. Never answer with their name. So disgusted with what happened. Hope everyone in this CW that was inconsiderate get karma for with what they put my mom & I through. Extremely shameful, inhumane. 😡 Not one person cared!!!!! I was telling when I first got this warranty to recommend people as I'm a good networking person. Not anymore. I will not recommend this company to anyone. I thought Sears was bad but wow this company is the worst for what they put my elderly handicapped mom & I through. No one would listen.

I have had home warranty coverage with Choice Home Warranty for a little over a year. During that time I have made two claims. One was just a blocked drain that was backing up and the other was a washing machine service. The first claim, which was the blocked drain they told me that it was not a covered service. I talked to a couple of people because the previous coverage I had covered that type of service. To make a long story short, they did not pay anything and I had to pay $300 out of pocket to get the drain cleared. I mentioned it to my sister-in-law, which is a top realtor in the city of Montgomery and she advised me that it was a covered service. When I called Choice back for the fourth time, they agreed that it should have been covered. Then on September 15, 2024 My washing machine would not turn on. I called choice and they did not schedule me a service call until September 26. I expressed to them that I needed something to be taking care of before then. They said they would check on it in call me back. Then, the next day I received an email that the September. 26th appointment had been canceled and they rescheduled it for October 1. I called and spoke to Supervisors, So they say after holding for 20 minutes or so. They said they would call the service company and try to get it expedited. That was a bunch of hogwash. I live in the capital city of Alabama, Montgomery, and they had no available technicians or service people here. Someone came from Columbus Georgia to service the washing machine. Of course it could not be repaired and I needed to get a replacement one. I have been at this point without a washing machine for over three weeks!!!!! To make things worse, The amount that they provided to purchase a washer was like a third of the least expensive one I could find. I called and mentioned that to a case manager, and he said that’s all Choice could pay. Then, to top it all off, they said they would not send out the funds until 30 days!!! Can you believe that?! This is the worst service I have ever contracted with in my life. I have been paying The monthly fee with a service fee of $75. I was advised that the monthly fee was going to increase as well as the service fee. All I can share is that this was the worst experience with a company that did not care about customer service or meeting the needs of their consumer. I would use anyone else before contracting with Choice Home Warranty. Especially with this last claim, I feel like they did not care or appreciate me as their client. My sister-in-law and realtor will no longer recommend or purchase this for her new clients.

Choice Home Warrenty is very difficult to communicate with. It takes multiple months to have an issue resolved after filing a claim. They have a very rude phone representative that spoke like an internet troll - It was very intentional. Of that experience, he said there was no record of claims and said electrical was denied. I ended the call and sent an follow up email for clarity with another, and nothing the troll said was true (which makes sence), home choice had every record, electrical claim hadn't been denied. I called the technician too who said the claim was open. A technician that came to my house twice warned me against choice home warranty letting me know I'd be facing frustration and time sucks from them. They shared an alternative company that they preferred. The technicians that actually do the work and have serviced the house have been phenomenal (but they do not work for choice home warranty directly).

Sent in 2 request and both times it has not been good. 1st request I put exactly what I wanted done, and they sent out a plumbing company to do they work. Problem is plumbing company stated this is not covered by warranty and I had to pay out of pocket. I understand why they wouldnt cover it, by why didnt Choice read my email and catch this. THIS IS YOUR JOB. 2nd request i specifically said I need to find someone on a Saturday due to my work schedule. Once again no one read my email and just scheduled it for a Friday. I immediately cancelled the work order. Choice only seems to care about getting a subscription renewed as I get 5 calls a day. Tried to overlook this and my account manager called and said he was going to email me and leave his personal information, but like I expected he never did. Worst experience with a warranty company ever!

Very disappointed with Choice. They could not find a plumber, so asked me to find one. I did and they did a great job. Choice refused to pay for the claim because the plumber didn't write up the work the way Choice wanted. Same thing for the electrician. Next, they did not want to get the part to fix my washer, so they issued money for me to buy my own replacement. The funds did not cover the cost of a like machine, but $400. Choice claims agent verified this fact, and advised that Choice does not give out new washers for old ones. They provide the funds for a similar unit at their cost, but will not help get the item at their cost.

They do not replace your appliances with equal or greater value as they claim to, they cash it out at their cost which is about a third of what you can actually buy it for, which is also cheaper than their willing to pay to repair the item, they paid me $1100 to replace a $3600 refrigerator & now $400 to replace a $1500 freezer They have lawsuits in different states for fraud, I personally am filing complaints with the attorney general & the BBB DONT FALL FOR THEIR SALES PITCH they used to be really good I’ve had them for over 15 years but they said they changed a couple years ago, & they won’t tell you that, it’s in the fine print

Spoke with Brandon J who I must say was very helpful and professional. Answered all my questions without pressuring me and was very pleased with his service.