Select Home Warranty: Read 3,955 User Reviews From Real Homeowners

star star star star star

H,M, Sharma Gurnee, IL

Mr. Williams called me within seconds after I went online on the website. He was able to set me up quickly and offered me more discounts. I appreciate his sincere help,

4 years ago

star star star star star_border

MI Powell San Jose, CA

Just signed up with Select, so I can't really rate accurately but I guess I will see how this company really is in time. I was very impressed with the representative. His name is Greg T.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Rita Bradshaw Ladson, SC

I called them about an electrical problem and was sent a message about 10 days later and told I would have to find my own electrician to do the work and get reimbursed. I was given a maximum amount of $100. which is about what it takes to get an electrician to come to your house. When i purchased my warranty the salesman represented the company as being able to repair or replace my broken appliance and never mentioned a depreciation of value. Admittedly this is partially my fault for not reading the contract in full. When I called to question these issues the representative was very friendly and did his best to appease me. However, I feel I was mislead on what they could do for me. I would not recommend this company to anyone. The salesmen tell you whatever they can to sell the plan and then you end up paying almost the whole thing anyway and have to get your own contractor so they are pretty useless.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Ashley Leyva Ulysses, KS

Just signed up so it was my first experience. I spoke with a very helpful representative who was able to get me started with a policy that worked for my home.

4 years ago

star star star star star_border

Jennifer W Boerne, TX

All of my claims have been scheduled with in 48 hours. Their process is easy to understand. Be sure to read your contract so you can thoroughly speak with the customer service agents.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Helen J Gwynn Phoenix, AZ

Select Home Warranty is always good with follow through, and I like the service providers they send to my house. All claims have been easy to work with Select.

4 years ago

star star star star star_border

Raymond Tavita Fresno, CA

Knowledgeable, and also found answers when he wasn't sure. Covered all and any of the discounts I qualified for. One of my better experience dealing with insurance representative.

4 years ago

star star star star star_border

Skybeats04 Gilbert, AZ

Home warranty sounds like the best bang for your buck and they will really work with you to find a common ground in billing. Try them out if you a home owner and want the best select the Select home warranty

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

sharon auger Lady Lake, FL

I submitted a claim for my dishwasher not releasing the water. It has been 3 months and 6 days without a dishwasher. The red tape and sending a company 1 1/2 hours away is ridiculous. I submitted initial claim Feb. 3rd, 2021, took 3 weeks for a tech to come to assess the problem, another 3 weeks to return with a part. Still did not work, another 3 weeks to return due to needing approval from SHW and the middle man that provides the parts, National Services Alliance. This tech from another fly-by-night company still 11/2 hours away simply looked at the problem and said he needed another part. 1 month later another tech arrives but this time without the right part which he needed to return the wrong part and get approval to order a different motor. Still waiting. Do not use this company.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Paul D Waldorf, MD

After a great experience chatting with Ed C., I chose Select Home Warranty to take care of my warranty needs . . . Best price and customer service around?

4 years ago

star star star star star

Kayla Horkley Boise, ID

Barry was very helpful in helping me select a plan that would be perfect for my home needs. He also saved me some money by doing the annual plan. Thank you!

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

paula rivers Humble, TX

I have been with this company Select Home Warranty since 2018 and have never had a satisfying claim with them. Every time I have made a claim I get so exhausted with the staff that I have had to have get the problem fixed myself. The last claim I filed with them was on my dryer and once they came out they depreciated by dryer down to 175.00 and was told I could get a used dryer but I had to pay for it first to get reimbursed. I made a claim on my dishwasher and was told I had to buy one first to get reimbursed for up to 175.00 and the replacement cost $99. I called company before my next bill was due to inform them that the debit card they were taking payments from had been compromised and I had to get another sent to me within 7 to 10 business days. I received more calls about when I was going to pay my bill and none for the reimbursement of the $99. I feel that this company is a fraud and takes money from their customers instead of helping them with problems they call about with issues in your home of items that suppose to be covered by this policy. I wouldn't recommend this company to my dog or anybody.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Martha Tijerina Denton, TX

I purchased this warranty when I bought my home. A few months after I moved in I had issues with my AC unit. I filed a claim with Select Home warranty and received an email that it was approved. I called to get some more information when I spoke to one of the reps I was told that my claim was denied because there was a 30 day waiting period from the time I purchased my policy I purchased my policy in February I filed a claim in April then was told it’s another 30 days from March, still was within guidelines, then they told me it was a 30 day cap? Ultimately i was told the motor wasn’t covered so it was denied. Very frustrating and disappointing. Would definitely not recommend.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Donna Lanford Panama City, FL

Sales representative was very courteous, and extremely helpful. He was not pushy. He offered me a additional benefits and answered all my questions.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Brian Armstrong Austin, TX

Flexibility on coverage and pricing. Did lots of research and this was the best deal out there! Tom Brown was very patient and answered all of our questions.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Don Utica, IL

Tom was very knowledgeable about the product and extremely helpful with all my questions that allowed me to make decision to purchase while we were on the call

4 years ago

star star star star star

Jay Gillespie Tucson, AZ

I got my questions answered plainly and candidly. Sam M. also asked and found ways to provide me a senior discount coupled with a multi year term. Very efficient.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Yuri McMutry Atlanta, GA

Please do NOT spend your money with this "Home Warranty" company. As a new customer to Select Home Warranty I am very disappointed and upset that I spent my money purchasing a policy with this company. This company has reimbursement issues, "hidden" probation periods of service, unexpected costs issues, misleading and lack of information when speaking with personnel, as well as poor communication when being transferred to different departments. In any "emergency" repair situation Select Home Warranty is NOT the company to call. Heaven forbid if there is a leak or plumbing issue in your home, you would have an entire swimming pool in your home before Select Home Warranty would send someone over to repair, IF they actually felt like taking the time out of their busy schedules to find a plumbing service nearest to you. Their "reimbursement" is a joke. They will ask for invoices indicating the service that was performed (that you pay for AFTER you pay for the policy) and will give you a refund of only $150. If anyone wanted to pay $300 - $500 for a home repair, then a home warranty policy wouldn't be needed. Long story short, I felt like I had been duped, and wish that I had read more reviews about Select Home Warranty company before I signed up with this circus. One pro to this company is that they have a hell of a sales team, because the person that sold me the policy did a great job of selling the paper that the policy documents were printed on, and an excellent job at concealing what a fraud Select Home Warranty company really is.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Joyce Menifee, CA

Sam was honest and professional. He provided outstanding service. He also informed us of additional incentives for seniors which we took advantage of. Great Job!

4 years ago

star star star star star

June R Hildebrandt Orange Park, FL

Ed C. was very helpful and knowledgeable. He answered all my questions politely and seemed to care that I was happy with the plan I chose. Thank you, Ed!!!

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Beth Weatherford, TX

They have good customer service and find services quickly. The problem is that contractors don’t want to come and service Select Home Warranty customers. My first time filing a claim, the contractor SHW provided me with(1st leak response) calling me back complaining about waiting for SHW payments for over 4 months, that contractor turn down my order and said he will not answer SHW phone calls. The second claim i submit, i called the contractor (Texan Mechanical) that SHW provided me with, to make an appointment. The contractor was ready to give me an appointment when i told him my order number and insurance name he said he was not setting appointment for “them” yet. SHW clients was not his priority. The third and last claim i submitted. The contractor (Lujano Plumbing) changed my appointment 4 times. When he came told me that Select Home Warranty wont cover my broken water pipe and wanted me to pay the whole service, part, labor etc to him and for me to submit a refund to SHW. He also complained about SHW owning him 15,000. This is how it goes with SHW. You submit a claim and it take 2 labor days to get you a contractor (if you call on Saturday it will take the 4 days). Then the contractor takes 2 days to give you an appointment. Then the contractor submit by email his report and it take SHW to 2 labor days to approve. Once approved contractor has to set up another appointment. It takes about 3 weeks to have the work done.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Emily Tanner Georgetown, TX

Ed made our process super simple and very quick. He was very easy to talk to and explained everything really well for us first time homebuyers. We appreciate it!

4 years ago

star star star star star

Sena Lee West Covina, CA

Jake H. was very professional, knowledgeable and kind. He wanted to help us out with the best plan that meets our needs. He made everything so easy. Thanks

4 years ago

star star star star star

Linda Martin California City, CA

Our representative Sol was very helpful And knowledgeable. He gave us the best price available and made the experience very pleasant. I highly recommend this company.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

JamesBuckhalt Headland, AL

We have paid on time a monthly payment for years now that we filed a claim we are getting the run around. Our AC went out Saturday four days again. I filed a claim immediately. The first AC said they did not deal with Select as it was a sorry company. Well they sent us the name of a second one. But he said he had not been authorized to come out by Select I’ve talked to about four representatives and everything one tell me something different. They want us to make pictures of the unit pictures of the serial number pictures of the model number. If they would just send a technician he would have all that As soon as this is settled we will cancel plan It is a sorry company

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Sha Oakland, CA

Horrible experience. DO NOT BUY this service. Website information is all a lie. 1- The website says the offer 24/7 service. That is a lie. They close at 4 pm est, & no call back options or services after business hours. 2- They ask to go to website & file a claim, Another big lie. their website doesn't work. you get stuck entering date or brand & can't file anything. 3- They say they have same day service. Another big lie. Once you get someone on the phone & submit a claim, you have to wait for 48 hours before someone contacts you & schedule a time which can be next week or next month. No same day or same week service. 4- if you are lucky, you get someone on the phone from claim department, which won't commit to any thing. 5- Finally you get an email that they don't have technicians available for next 3- 4 weeks & we should hire our own technician. But we need authorization from them & after we hire a technician & pay for his/her time, we have to call & get authorization from them. They can decide whether to authorize the work or not to pay at all If you still buy their service then good luck to you.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Thuan Claremont, CA

Please all buyers and sellers. Don't go with Select Home Warranty. We purchase a home and our seller paid for the basic coverage. We paid for the upgrade to platinum coverage. When our water heater broke, we had to pay for a company to come out for $125 to look at it. Once they determined that it needed to be relieved replaced, all that was covered was $150. The heater replacement was $1300. We ended up using an outside company where we were able to choose the brand of the water heater and got a bigger one than the broken one. It only cost us $680. This company is in it with their subcontractors to take your money. Upgrading to platinum only put more money into their pockets. In the end, we were out of pocket for the contractor to come and for the platinum upgrade. Customer service is very bad. We had to call and email them a dozen times just to find out that they approved us for $150. Ridiculous!

4 years ago

star star star star star

Michaela Round Rock, TX

Sam M. with Select Home Warranty was great! He responded promptly to my inquiry, answered all my questions, and was very professional and friendly. I couldn't be happier!

4 years ago

star star star star_border star_border

T ,

I just signed up and spoke with Ed. While he was very knowledgeable, I could tell he was getting impatient with me and the questions I had since I’m a new home owner. I have seen a lot of good reviews but after talking with him I have been questioning if I made a mistake. I’m hoping my experience with the warranty procedures will be better.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Lawrence A. Lark Apopka, FL

Following a comprehensive review of available programs I found Select to be far and away the best choice . My hope is that you will continue in the same vein.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Misty Hollars Roswell, GA

We recently purchased a new home, and went with Select for our home warranty. The sales woman said our contract would start March 1st. However, she didn’t factor in Feb only having 28 days. So, I called about repairing a fridge leak around March 2nd. I placed the call less than 12 hours before the warranty actually kicked in (even though she said the 1st). They denied the claim. I had someone come out and paid to have it fixed but the problem started again. I tried calling Select several times, requesting a call back in que, but I never received a call. Once I FINALLY got through to them they are still denying service due to it being a pre-existing problem. This home warranty isn’t worth your money. Stick to American Home Shield. That’s who we had at our old home and never had a single problem with them. I am canceling Select today and reordering American Home Shield. I suggest all other customers do the same. To Select.. I am very disappointed in how you run your company. You are taking peoples money only to deny them service. Shame on you! 😡

4 years ago

star star star star star

Thomas Hastings ,

Enrollment could not have been easier. Their representative, Greg T., clearly explained all of our options and coverage and answered all of our questions.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Angela Ward Chicago, IL

The Agent, Daniel C., was very patient and waited for my return call. There was no red tape or delay in processing my request. He made it very easy.

4 years ago

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Msattack ,

We have NEVER had anything but trouble from the company. Their staff seems to know nothing except "WE ARE SORRY"; 'LET ME PUT YOU ON HOLD FOR A FEW MINUTES"; "AGAIN, WE APOLOGIZE FOR THE INCONVENIENCE". A customer can not contact corporate office, anyone in management or anyone with authority to resolve an issue. They promise the MOON, but cover "almost" nothing. They contract with people that do not work weekends (in case of emergency). Then they give you permission to contact a company that can service the residence on a weekend, give approval for the repair to be made and then DENY to reimburse the billed amount AFTER GIVING VERBAL APPROVAL TO CONSUMER AND SERVICE PROVIDER!! This is SCHLOCK COMPANY THAT CANNOT BE TRUSTED!!! BUYER BEWARE!!! They will NOT provide an address for contacting their legal department and they will NOT forward to anyone in authority. We paid in advance for 5 years back in May of 2018. They know they have us by the B--ls.

4 years ago

Reply from Select Home Warranty

We are sorry for the experience you have had. Please call our customer service dept. at 855-267-3532 x 5, We will do our best to satisfy your needs

Mar. 17th, 2021

star star star star star

Ernest Esparza Big Bear Lake, CA

Sam M., was the person that Helped Me. I was in the process of getting quotes, Select Home Warranty was the lowest and Sam made it affordable for me to start today.

4 years ago

star star star star star_border

deborah clay Hollister, CA

Can't say what I like best about the company yet. I just purchased agreement with them this week. I will evaluate as required in the future. But the servicer agent Sean Green was very good.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Larry R Thrash San Jose, CA

Richard was very patient with us. He did not try to upsale us; he explained all the details and let us make up our minds. He was very professional, friendly and helpful.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Kevin Hernandez Iselin, NJ

John was very professional and assisted my wife and I. Just amazing customer skill!!!! I'm looking forward to the Sevice ASAP!!!! The Select Home Warranty.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Rogers Family Salt Lake City, UT

This company was easy to work with and is cheaper than other companies, I love how easy the coverage was and excited to get the 3 year plan when we have the finances in order

4 years ago Edited September 14, 2021

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Roy Dalmacio League City, TX

This company is just awful. I had a claim submitted on a Wednesday to fix my drain problem. They said wait 1-2 business days for someone to reach out or call you. Two days had past and nothing. I called back Saturday and they told me I had to wait till Tuesday next week for a reply. So I was patient and waited. Fast forward, a technician finally came Thursday the following week and looked into the problem and wasn't able to fix and suggested I call back SHW to send out a plumber. It took forever for the customer service rep to answer then when I finally got someone, he said we need to submit a new claim and wait another 1-2 business days. I could personally find my own plumber within the day and get the problem fixed right away. I'm totally livid. Had to cancel since their S.O.P. totally sucks!

4 years ago

Reply from Select Home Warranty

We are sorry for the experience you have had. Please call our customer service dept. at 855-267-3532 x 5, We will do our best to satisfy your needs

Mar. 11th, 2021

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Tim Bradley Camarillo, CA

I purchased a Home warrant plan in which the sales person Noah C. kept making the deal better and better. Eventually we agreed to a 5 year plan, which became a six year plan. I asked for him to include my icemaker, which, in writing, he agreed. Now several months later the icemaker is not working. I called with my problem and very specifically told them it was my icemaker. The technician company called and an appointment was made. The technician was very courteous, although he spoke very, very minimal English. He showed me the problem and told me the icemaker basket would require replacement. Several days later I get an email informing me that the icemaker is not covered. I called and spoke to a representative who spoke very limited English but I was told that the icemaker is not covered. When I explained that I have it included as an addendum, in writing, I was basically informed "too bad". I have sent several emails to Noah. Not one has been returned. When I finally spoke to him (I called) he said he was two weeks behind responding to emails. One month later and still crickets. This is a very dishonest company. Buyer beware!!! I would never recommend this company. And their customer service is as poor as any I have ever encountered in my life. Tim Bradley

4 years ago

Reply from Select Home Warranty

We are sorry for the experience you have had. Please call our customer service dept. at 855-267-3532 x 5, We will do our best to satisfy your needs

Mar. 11th, 2021

star star star star star

Roger Renslow Peoria, AZ

I called to inquire about the service and was happy to get a thorough explanation of the plans and coverage in words I could understand. I did not hesitate to start plan.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Ginny Mesquite, TX

Lucas S. professionally informed me of the plan options but respected when I wasn’t interested in all of them. He was patient to find a plan that worked for me!

4 years ago

star star star star star

Timothy Lesperance Fort Worth, TX

After American Home Shield doubles prices while cutting coverage, Select offered a greater coverage with better value. Thanks to Ben for setting us up!

4 years ago Edited September 14, 2021

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Keith A Falks Belleville, MI

I had select home warranty plan for eighty-one days when I called to make a claim because my water heater had quit working. I called them on a Saturday day and did not hear anything back until the following Thursday. When they did call me back it was a landscape company calling to come out and check my hot water heater. I subsequently went ahead and purchased the hot water heater on Saturday when I didn't get a call back. I then cancelled my policy and then even though they broke the contract without having someone call me back within 72 hours they charged me 75.00 for cancelling the warranty. I found out through talking with these people that the company is from overseas and they are not a US company. PLEASE DO NOT BUY A HOME WARRANTY PLAN FROM THESE PEOPLE!!!! MY MISTAKE. IT COST ME 180.00 FOR HAVING THE WARRANTY FOR EIGHTY ONE DAYS.

4 years ago

Reply from Select Home Warranty

We are sorry for the experience you have had. Please call our customer service dept. at 855-267-3532 x 5, We will do our best to satisfy your needs

Feb. 25th, 2021

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Elena Pleasant Hill, CA

You strive for customer service satisfaction is again a false advertisement . Worst customer service. Worst service delivery ever. Misleading advertisements. My refrigerator stopped working , about 4 years old . French door , bought it for $1750.00. Repair can’t repair because it would cost money to replace parts. I was told they are giving to $185.00 to repair it, or buy a new refrigerator at my cost anything above $185.00 this is just my first complain. Having Select home warranty was so far the worst ever. It does not serve the purpose of having it. It doesn’t give you peace of mind like what they are claiming. They take your payment and they rebuttal every reason why they won’t repair/ replace like what their advertisement is saying . Select is a fraud . They refuse to give me back my money . Their reviews are also Falsely written . My property manager had a hard time getting them on the phone. .... property managers I know are staying away from them . Where are these 5 star reviews coming from. Home owners! Beware and read their fine prints .... they are not what you think Select Home Warranty is there for you . They are their to just take your money . I am still waiting for my$185.00 dollars back since it’s the best thing that they can come with. .they refuse to have a mechanic repair it at their cost . A dime spent to this company is too much . Can you imagine making calls on an AC ?

4 years ago

Reply from Select Home Warranty

We are sorry for the experience you have had. Please call our customer service dept. at 855-267-3532 x 5, We will do our best to satisfy your needs

Feb. 25th, 2021

star star star star star

Michael & Nancy Howard West Valley City, UT

Lucas S. is a very good sales rep from Select home warranty. He explained the features of the policy and how to use if needed. I would highly recommend him.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Gregory W Sauter Spring, TX

Friendly and helpful service. Customer service rep. Tom B. answered all of my many questions and help get me a great rate for my home warranty policy.

4 years ago

star star star star star

Penny Preston Cabot, AR

We just signed up, but find the conditions of the contract are reasonable, and that we will have a much better experience with you that our old provider.

4 years ago

star star star star star

BURTON ARISCO The Colony, TX

I liked how thorough Sol was with the program. As a senior it helps protect my investment. I also like that we can use our our service professionals if needed. Burton

4 years ago

Select Home Warranty Reviews