Best Auto Insurance

82 Companies

1,111 Real Customer Reviews

4.3
Average User Rating

Why I can trust BestCompany.com
Compare The Top Auto Insurance CompaniesSort By:
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $102-118
  • State Availability: 47
  • Year Established: 1984

The General

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $102-118
  • State Availability: 47
  • Year Established: 1984
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1998

Esurance Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1998
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1985

21st Century Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1985
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 16
  • Year Established: 1993

SafeAuto

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 16
  • Year Established: 1993
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $196.29
  • State Availability: 43
  • Year Established: 1916

Dairyland

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $196.29
  • State Availability: 43
  • Year Established: 1916
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 17
  • Year Established: Undisclosed

Acceptance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 17
  • Year Established: Undisclosed
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1958

AARP

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1958
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 36
  • Year Established: 1882

Chubb

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 36
  • Year Established: 1882
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 48
  • Year Established: 1920

National General

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 48
  • Year Established: 1920
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 26
  • Year Established: 1916

Auto-Owners.com

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 26
  • Year Established: 1916
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $102-118
  • State Availability: 47
  • Year Established: 1984

Headquartered in Nashville, TN, The General Insurance Company was designed to give those drivers with less-than-perfect records affordable auto insurance. The company operates in 47 of the 50 states, and provides a variety of services, but all premiums cover the minimum requirements of each specific state. The company is part of PGC holdings group, which has been writing auto insurance throughout a large portion of the country for 50 years.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1998

Esurance is an Allstate brand that has been a popular company for auto insurance and for customers who travel outside of the U.S. to Mexico and Canada. One of the initial selling points of the company was that it offered comparison quotes on its website, allowing consumers to compare rates with other major insurance companies. Since then, many other insurance companies have begun offering comparison quotes. Allstate acquired Esurance in 2011, and it now offers homeowner's insurance and health insurance.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1985

Founded in 1958 by Louis W. Foster, 21st Century is a large insurance company in America. AIG bought it in 2005, ultimately selling it to Farmers Insurance Group in 2009. Primarily based out of Wilmington, Delaware, they offer insurance in 49 states as well as in Washington D.C. They cover more than 10 million households as well as over 20 million policies across America, with over 50,000 independent agents and close to 24,000 employees across the nation.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 16
  • Year Established: 1993

Founded in 1993, SafeAuto is an auto insurance carrier based out of Columbus, Ohio. Jon Diamond and Ari Deshe founded the company, which, to this day, remains privately owned. From the start, the company's intention has been to provide reasonably priced policies to high-risk clients. The company offers health insurance as well as car insurance plans. While there are a number of beneficial features and services to take advantage of, there are also limitations to the SafeAuto platform.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $196.29
  • State Availability: 43
  • Year Established: 1916

Dairyland has been hard at work insuring riders and drivers since for decades. Originally, the company started out by writing auto insurance, but eventually started to provide motorcycle insurance. While Dairyland is based in Wisconsin, they sell insurance on a nationwide level. Their headquarters are in Wisconsin, but there are branches and customer service centers all across the country. The Dairyland platform is built on providing competitive rates, money-saving discounts, and a high-level of customer service to auto and motorcycle clients.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 17
  • Year Established: Undisclosed

Company has not yet verified this profile. We recommend researching the top companies shown below:

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1958

AARP has partnered with The Hartford Group since 1989 to provide auto insurance for AARP members and non-members alike. AARP is currently headquartered out of the District of Columbia (Washington, DC). They are a large nonprofit organization with around 5,000 employees. They pride themselves in their unique benefits, low rates, and quality service to every state but Massachusetts in the United States.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 36
  • Year Established: 1882

Chubb is one of the world's largest publicly traded property and casualty insurers. They operate in 54 countries worldwide and provide: commercial and personal property and casualty insurance, personal accident and supplemental health insurance, reinsurance and life insurance to their clients. Chubb insurance is available to individuals and families as well as businesses. For individuals and families, automobile, valuables, watercraft, excess liability, and personal accidental health insurance is available. With executive offices in a number of locations, it is no surprise that Chubb employs over 31,000 people worldwide.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 48
  • Year Established: 1920

Company has not yet verified this profile. We recommend researching the top companies shown below:

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 26
  • Year Established: 1916

Auto-Owners.com is the web presence of a clearinghouse of independent insurance brokers. They were founded in 1916 and have been providing financial services products since. The company is comprised of five property and casualty companies, paired with an annuity and life/health insurer. The company is headquartered in Lansing, Michigan. Prospective policyholders enter their information and receive a series of quotes based upon this information. Coverages vary greatly by the policyholder's state of residence.

View Company Profile