Best Auto Insurance

82 Companies

818 Real Customer Reviews

4.2
Average User Rating

Why I can trust BestCompany.com
Dear Friends,

This industry page does not have enough reviews to provide you with accurate scoring. We’re working hard to gather reviews from real customers. If you've had an experience with any company in this industry, please leave a review.

If you'd like us to contact you when we've established a ranking that we are confident putting our name behind, please leave us with your email address.

We will only use your email to notify you when this industry page has an established ranking.
Message to Companies....

To ensure we provide the most accurate information possible for consumers, please ensure you've claimed your business profile. We look forward to hearing from you!

Claim Profile
Read More
Compare The Top Auto Insurance CompaniesSort By:

4.9

Overall Score

10 User Reviews

13 days ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $237
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1907

Amica

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $237
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1907

4.7

Overall Score

16 User Reviews

a month ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $101.38
  • State Availability: 11
  • Year Established: 1925

Erie Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $101.38
  • State Availability: 11
  • Year Established: 1925

4.3

Overall Score

16 User Reviews

a month ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $110-129
  • State Availability: 19
  • Year Established: 1954

American Family Insurance-Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $110-129
  • State Availability: 19
  • Year Established: 1954

4.0

Overall Score

11 User Reviews

3 months ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 10
  • Year Established: 1810

The Hartford

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 10
  • Year Established: 1810

3.2

Overall Score

12 User Reviews

7 days ago

  • Independent Insurance Company
  • Customer Service Oriented
  • Only Available in One State

Square State Insurance

  • Independent Insurance Company
  • Customer Service Oriented
  • Only Available in One State

3.1

Overall Score

20 User Reviews

a month ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132.17
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1928

Farmers Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132.17
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1928
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $95.50
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1869

MetLife

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $95.50
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1869
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $102-118
  • State Availability: 47
  • Year Established: 1984

The General

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $102-118
  • State Availability: 47
  • Year Established: 1984
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1998

Esurance Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1998
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1985

21st Century Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1985

Amica

4.9Overall Score
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $237
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1907

Established in 1907, Amica (The Automobile Mutual Insurance Company of America) was introduced to the insurance industry long before many of its competitors. The company's headquarters are located in Lincoln, Rhode Island, although they were originally housed in Providence upon its founding. While it is unclear how many employees the company houses, there are 44 offices across the country-a dynamic number in comparison to other companies. Its popularity has grown over the years, especially after it appeared on Fortune 1000 in the year 2007.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $101.38
  • State Availability: 11
  • Year Established: 1925

Erie Insurance was founded in 1925 and is headquartered in Pennsylvania. The company offers their financial services and insurance products to many in the eastern United States. The company offers their customers all of the basic coverages which one can expect in an auto insurance policy, with several added features. Some of the added features and benefits are available without adding additional charges to the policyholder.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $110-129
  • State Availability: 19
  • Year Established: 1954

American Family Insurance wide range of products and services, including auto, home, life and health insurance, as well as retirement products. With a focus on providing a wide range of insurance types, the company's slogan is, "All your protection under one roof." However, many of their competitors offer a much greater selection, giving customers greater variety, so they can put together a highly customized insurance policy.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 10
  • Year Established: 1810

Company has not yet verified this profile. We recommend researching the top companies shown below:

View Company Profile
  • Independent Insurance Company
  • Customer Service Oriented
  • Only Available in One State

Square State Insurance is an independent insurance agency founded on three key ideals: service, savings, and selection. Square State Insurance clients have their agent’s cell phone number and routinely save over 50 percent off their insurance premiums. Unlike most agencies, Square State Insurance has insurance brokers with access to numerous insurance carriers.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132.17
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1928

Farmers Insurance was founded in 1928 and is currently headquartered in Los Angeles, California. Originally designed to meet automobile insurance needs for farmers and ranchers, who had statistically better driving records than those living in metropolitan areas, the company has grown with agents in 50 states.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $95.50
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1869

MetLife is one of the leading global insurance providers, with more than 90 million customers worldwide. The company holds leading market positions throughout the United States, Latin America, Japan, Europe, the Middle East and Asia.With MetLife, clients can expect to receive quality insurance coverage that is handled in an effective manner. Their coverage spans across the country and helps millions of drivers stay safe on the road. Even though there are a number of beneficial features and services included in MetLife's policies, there are concerns that need to be analyzed prior to making a decision.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $102-118
  • State Availability: 47
  • Year Established: 1984

Headquartered in Nashville, TN, The General Insurance Company was designed to give those drivers with less-than-perfect records affordable auto insurance. The company operates in 47 of the 50 states, and provides a variety of services, but all premiums cover the minimum requirements of each specific state. The company is part of PGC holdings group, which has been writing auto insurance throughout a large portion of the country for 50 years.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $129-145
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1998

Esurance is an Allstate brand that has been a popular company for auto insurance and for customers who travel outside of the U.S. to Mexico and Canada. One of the initial selling points of the company was that it offered comparison quotes on its website, allowing consumers to compare rates with other major insurance companies. Since then, many other insurance companies have begun offering comparison quotes. Allstate acquired Esurance in 2011, and it now offers homeowner's insurance and health insurance.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $132
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1985

Founded in 1958 by Louis W. Foster, 21st Century is a large insurance company in America. AIG bought it in 2005, ultimately selling it to Farmers Insurance Group in 2009. Primarily based out of Wilmington, Delaware, they offer insurance in 49 states as well as in Washington D.C. They cover more than 10 million households as well as over 20 million policies across America, with over 50,000 independent agents and close to 24,000 employees across the nation.

View Company Profile