Best Auto Insurance

82 Companies

1,111 Real Customer Reviews

4.3
Average User Rating

Why I can trust BestCompany.com
Compare The Top Auto Insurance CompaniesSort By:

6.2

Overall Score

21 User Reviews

10 days ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $112-$151
  • State Availability: 46
  • Year Established: 1926

Nationwide Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $112-$151
  • State Availability: 46
  • Year Established: 1926

6.0

Overall Score

17 User Reviews

2 months ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $117
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1923

Safeco Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $117
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1923

5.9

Overall Score

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $151
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1912

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $151
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1912

5.7

Overall Score

11 User Reviews

3 months ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $237
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1907

Amica

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $237
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1907

5.5

Overall Score

13 User Reviews

2 months ago

  • Independent Insurance Company
  • Customer Service Oriented
  • Only Available in One State

Square State Insurance

  • Independent Insurance Company
  • Customer Service Oriented
  • Only Available in One State

5.4

Overall Score

13 User Reviews

3 months ago

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 10
  • Year Established: 1810

The Hartford

  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 10
  • Year Established: 1810

5.2

Overall Score

  • Operates in Utah
  • High Quality Personalized Service
  • Personal Auto, Homeowners, Fire and Umbrella Insurance Claims

Bear River Insurance

  • Operates in Utah
  • High Quality Personalized Service
  • Personal Auto, Homeowners, Fire and Umbrella Insurance Claims
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $66.30
  • State Availability: 11
  • Year Established: 2006

Direct Auto & Life Insurance

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $66.30
  • State Availability: 11
  • Year Established: 2006
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $95.50
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1869

MetLife

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $95.50
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1869
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $83.35
  • State Availability: Undisclosed
  • Year Established: 1999

Freedom National

  • Average Monthly Pricing: $83.35
  • State Availability: Undisclosed
  • Year Established: 1999
#11
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $112-$151
  • State Availability: 46
  • Year Established: 1926

Nationwide Insurance was founded as the Farm Bureau Mutual Automobile Insurance Company in Columbus, Ohio in 1925. Initially, auto insurance policies were offered primarily to area farmers. In 1928, the company expanded into West Virginia then moved from farms to small towns in 1931. By 1943, they had spread across 12 states and offered policies in big cities as well as small towns and rural areas.

View Company Profile
#12
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $117
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1923

Since becoming part of Liberty Mutual, Safeco has narrowed its focus to personal insurance, offering an array of coverage options for homes, vehicles and more. The company employs over 7,200 people across the nation. While Safeco provides a relatively comprehensive product, in terms of their service area, there are some serious limitations to the platform as well.

View Company Profile
#13
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $151
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1912

Liberty Mutual offers everything from auto and homeowners insurance to workers' comp and commercial insurance. The insurer has acquired a number of smaller companies, including Safeco Corp. and Wausau Insurance. Through local insurance companies owned or affiliated with Liberty Mutual, the company offers policies in many countries, including but not limited to Brazil, India, Russia, Spain, Thailand, Turkey, the United Kingdom and Vietnam.

View Company Profile
#14

Amica

5.7Overall Score
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $237
  • State Availability: 49
  • Year Established: 1907

Established in 1907, Amica (The Automobile Mutual Insurance Company of America) was introduced to the insurance industry long before many of its competitors. The company's headquarters are located in Lincoln, Rhode Island, although they were originally housed in Providence upon its founding. While it is unclear how many employees the company houses, there are 44 offices across the country-a dynamic number in comparison to other companies. Its popularity has grown over the years, especially after it appeared on Fortune 1000 in the year 2007.

View Company Profile
#15
  • Independent Insurance Company
  • Customer Service Oriented
  • Only Available in One State

Square State Insurance is an independent insurance agency founded on three key ideals: service, savings, and selection. Square State Insurance clients have their agent’s cell phone number and routinely save over 50 percent off their insurance premiums. Unlike most agencies, Square State Insurance has insurance brokers with access to numerous insurance carriers.

View Company Profile
#16
  • Average Monthly Pricing: Undisclosed
  • State Availability: 10
  • Year Established: 1810

Company has not yet verified this profile. We recommend researching the top companies shown below:

View Company Profile
#17
  • Operates in Utah
  • High Quality Personalized Service
  • Personal Auto, Homeowners, Fire and Umbrella Insurance Claims

Company has not yet verified this profile. We recommend researching the top companies shown below:

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $66.30
  • State Availability: 11
  • Year Established: 2006

Direct Auto and Life Insurance was the first insurance company in the Direct General Group. It was founded on April 12,1991 by William Adair. Adair had a vision to create an option for all drivers when it comes to obtaining auto insurance. Serving the southeast, Direct Auto has found a way to provide customers with competitive rates, flexible payment plans, and general services regardless of their past driving history.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $95.50
  • State Availability: 50
  • Year Established: 1869

MetLife is one of the leading global insurance providers, with more than 90 million customers worldwide. The company holds leading market positions throughout the United States, Latin America, Japan, Europe, the Middle East and Asia.With MetLife, clients can expect to receive quality insurance coverage that is handled in an effective manner. Their coverage spans across the country and helps millions of drivers stay safe on the road. Even though there are a number of beneficial features and services included in MetLife's policies, there are concerns that need to be analyzed prior to making a decision.

View Company Profile
  • Average Monthly Pricing: $83.35
  • State Availability: Undisclosed
  • Year Established: 1999

Freedom National has provided auto insurance since 1999. Freedom National works to maintain a high-level of professionalism while providing quality insurance at a competitive price. They constantly refine their insurance solutions and products to keep their customers satisfied. The Freedom National platform comes with a number of beneficial product features and discounts to take advantage of. Additionally, Freedom National customers can manage their policy and payments online without ever having to pick up the phone.

View Company Profile