How to Choose the Right Gutter Company for Your Home

Gutters may not be the most exciting part of homeownership, but they do a lot of heavy lifting when it comes to protecting your house from water damage. Choosing the right gutter company can mean the difference between a system that lasts for decades and one that constantly needs repairs. 

But with so many companies out there, how do you know which one to trust?

To help you narrow down your choices, we’ve put together this comprehensive guide on how to choose the best gutter company.

1. Decide what types of gutters you want
2. Choose the right material
3. Compare warranties
4. Verify company credentials
5. Schedule an on-site evaluation
6. Read customer reviews

1. Decide What Types of Gutters You Want

Believe it or not, gutters come in different styles and shapes, each with its own pros and cons. Choosing the right type will impact not only how well they work but also how they look on your home.

Common Types of Gutters

• Sectional gutters — Made from pre-cut sections joined together. Easy to install but prone to leaks at the seams over time.
• Seamless gutters — Custom-made for your home, meaning fewer leaks and less maintenance.
• Half-round gutters — Rounded bottom, often chosen for their traditional aesthetic appeal.
• K-style gutters — The most popular choice for modern homes, with a decorative shape that mimics crown molding.

2. Choose the Right Material

Once you’ve considered the gutter style you want, it’s also important to consider the material because it can impact the lifespan of your gutters and their overall performance.

Common Gutter Materials

• Aluminum: Affordable, rust-resistant, and lightweight. A top pick for many homeowners.
• Copper: Expensive but incredibly durable. Plus, it develops a unique patina over time.
• Steel: Strong and weather-resistant but may rust if not properly maintained.
• Vinyl: Budget-friendly and easy to install, but not as durable in extreme weather.
• Wood: Rare and mainly used for historic restorations. High maintenance and prone to rot.

3. Compare Warranties

Comparing gutter company warranties is a crucial step in choosing the right provider for your gutter installation or replacement project — a good warranty can offer peace of mind and protect your investment. But not all warranties are created equal. Here’s what to look for:

1. What’s Covered? Most companies offer warranties on materials, workmanship, and performance. Some combine them into one comprehensive warranty.
2. How Long Does It Last? Material warranties can range from 20 years to a lifetime, while workmanship warranties typically last 1–10 years.
3. Is It Transferable? If you sell your home, a transferable warranty can add value.
4. Prorated vs. Non-Prorated. A prorated warranty covers less over time, meaning you might pay more for repairs later. A non-prorated warranty keeps full coverage for the entire term.

Most gutter companies offer a lifetime warranty, usually as one all-inclusive plan. A solid warranty is a good sign that the company stands behind its work. Just be sure to check the fine print: coverage, exclusions, and limits can vary. Knowing what’s included can help you pick the best gutter company.

4. Verify Company Credentials

Make sure the gutter company has proper licensing, insurance, and certifications. A reputable company should be able to provide proof of these upon request. 

Also, keep in mind that experience is a plus, but it’s not everything. A company with years in the business might be reliable, but a newer one could offer just as good (or even better) service. Focus on their reputation and quality of work, not just how long they’ve been around.

5. Schedule an On-Site Evaluation

Before making a decision, schedule a consultation so the company can assess your home and provide an accurate estimate.

This is also your chance to ask questions about the installation process, materials, warranties, and timeline. Pay attention to how professional and knowledgeable they are. It’s often a good indicator of their service quality.

6. Read Customer Reviews

One of the best ways to judge a company's reliability is by reading customer reviews. Just keep in mind that people are often more likely to leave a review after a bad experience than a good one, so consider the overall feedback rather than focusing on just a few negative comments.

Two of the most highly rated gutter companies on BestCompany.com are:

LeafFilter Gutter Protection

Get A Quote

On BestCompany.com LeafFilter Gutter Protection reviews are overwhelmingly positive — 91 percent of reviews are 4 or 5 stars. Satisfied LeafFilter Gutter Protection customers are quick to mention the following about their experience with the company:

• Superb gutter guard functionality — many customers indicate that their gutters never clog and they don’t have to worry about cleaning them
• Comprehensive warranty coverage
• Responsive customer service — if you have any issues with your gutter system, the LeafFilter team will come to your home to fix the problem

LeafGuard

Get A Quote

On BestCompany.com, 81 percent of LeafGuard reviews are 4 or 5 stars. LeafGuard customers frequently highlight the following about their experience with the company:

• Great upfront customer service — LeafGuard representatives can answer questions and address concerns
• Quick and easy gutter installation process
• Good value for the system and service — many customers note that the LeafGuard price tag is higher than other gutter companies, but the higher price is worth it