LeafFilter Gutter Protection vs Gutter Helmet
If you’re looking for lasting gutter protection that won’t require you to get up on a ladder yourself to clean your gutters, LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet could be good options to consider.
LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet are both recognized and trusted names in the gutter industry. Both companies offer patented gutter guard solutions that are installed directly on your existing gutters, providing year-round debris protection while maintaining the flow of rainwater. Differences between the companies’ gutter products are primarily due to design, but both LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet’s gutter systems will perform similarly — your gutters will be kept clear and unclogged, and you won’t have to worry about cleaning your gutters yourself.
Continue reading for a detailed breakdown of LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet’s products and services, as well as an overview of customer sentiment for each company.
Overview
LeafFilter Gutter Protection
19 Years
Gutter Helmet
43 Years
Ratings
LeafFilter Gutter Protection
Gutter Helmet
Pros & Cons
LeafFilter Gutter Protection
PROS
- Micromesh gutter filter technology
- Durable uPVC gutter frame
- Lifetime warranty
CONS
- Filters may need to be changed over time
- Lifetime warranty is non-transferable
- Not available to residents in AK, AZ, and HI
Gutter Helmet
PROS
- 7 patented gutter features
- Filter-free gutter technology
- No maintenance required
- Heat cable technology to protect against snow and ice
- Transferable lifetime warranty
CONS
- Not available in all states
- Must be installed by Gutter Helmet professionals
Reviews
LeafFilter Gutter Protection
Reviews
Gutter Helmet
Reviews for LeafFilter Gutter Protection
Helpful Favorable Review
Wilkening
October 23rd, 2024
DETAILS
Verified Customer
Review Source
So far, since installation, there has been zero rain for over 30 days. However, with plenty of wind and strong gusts, pine needles and leaves slide off the roof onto the LeafFilter to the ground. Perfect.
Helpful Critical Review
Wilson
July 2nd, 2024
DETAILS
Verified Customer
Review Source
I was told that debris would dry out and fly away and I don’t need gutter cleaning anymore. Debris has built up and not left. Two gutter cleaning companies have told me regardless of leaf filter you still need two annual cleanings. Very disappointing.
Reviews for Gutter Helmet
Helpful Favorable Review
Helpful Critical Review
The Final Word
Gutter protection products
While both LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet’s gutter systems perform similarly, there are differences in design that are worth noting.
| LeafFilter | Gutter Helmet | |
| Fits on existing gutters | ✔ | ✔ |
| Patented features | ✔ | ✔ |
| Mesh filter technology | ✔ | ✘ |
| Reinforced structural supports | ✔ | ✔ |
| All-weather protection | ✔ | ✔ |
As noted above, the largest difference between the LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet systems is the use of mesh filter technology to keep debris from entering gutters. Both companies offer products that will effectively keep your gutters clean, but there could be a chance that you may need to replace LeafFilter gutter filters at some point, as they pose a higher risk of becoming clogged themselves. However, the LeafFilter gutter product uses extremely fine mesh that should reduce the need for any maintenance.
The patented LeafFilter gutter product is a filtering system made of 275 micron steel mesh — at 275 microns fine, not even a single grit or pine needle will get through the micromesh. The mesh is combined with a uPVC frame with built-in pitch that will shed debris, as well as structural hangers that are fastened to your fascia board. It’s worth noting that the uPVC material used for the gutter frame also ensures that the frame won’t warp or deteriorate over time due to weather extremes.
Gutter Helmet seeks to provide the most permanent gutter guard solution possible. The Gutter Helmet gutter product varies from LeafFilter’s product by using a debris shedding design instead of a filter. Gutter Helmet includes seven patented features that maintains water flow through gutters while shedding any debris, and the system includes load-bearing supports that are reinforced and anti-corrosive.
In addition to its gutter guard product, Gutter Helmet offers its Helmet Heat® ice reduction system, a self-regulating heat cable that can be installed with your gutter guard to keep snow and ice from building up on the edges of your roof. The Helmet Heat cables can be installed on a new or existing Gutter Helmet, and the cables will be hidden underneath your gutter guard cover, keeping them invisible while also protected. Thus, if you live in a particularly cold climate and/or an area that experiences harsh winters, Gutter Helmet would be a better choice for you.
Cost
Neither LeafFilter nor Gutter Helmet provide specific price points for their products. Gutter guard installations will vary depending on house size, existing gutters, etc.; thus, neither company would be able to provide accurate pricing for all customers. Both LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet do offer free estimates, allowing you to receive a more accurate cost estimate for your project, while also providing you with an opportunity to speak with a company representative and ask any questions you may have.
Lifetime warranty
Both LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet provide lifetime warranties with their gutter guard products. Thus, whether you choose LeafFilter or Gutter Helmet, your gutters will be protected from damage for as long as you live in your home.
It’s important to note that the Gutter Helmet lifetime warranty is also transferable, ensuring that, if you should move, the next homeowners retain gutter protection.
Time in business
While a company’s time in business isn’t necessarily an indicator of a company’s quality, some customers may find greater peace of mind working with a company that has been active in the industry for a longer period of time.
Both LeafFilter and Gutter Helmet have been providing gutter services for decades. However, Gutter Helmet has a longer history in the industry, having been established in 1981. LeafFilter was established in 2005.
Customer reviews
On BestCompany.com, LeafFilter currently has upwards of 1,500 reviews, whereas Gutter Helmet doesn’t currently have any customer reviews. Thus, we’re unable to provide an accurate comparison of these gutter companies based on customer sentiment at this time.
However, it’s worth highlighting the fact that 91 percent of LeafFilter reviews are 4 or 5 stars. Satisfied LeafFilter customers are quick to highlight the effectiveness of the LeafFilter product, as well as how quick and efficient the installation process is. Based on these reviews, LeafFilter could be a good choice for your gutter guard needs.
Our recommendation
Based on the products and services available, we would recommend either LeafFilter or Gutter Helmet for your gutter guard needs. Both companies are leading names in the industry, and both companies promise effective gutter guards that will keep your gutters clog-free.
