Medical Guardian vs MobileHelp

McCall Martin
McCall Martin | Senior Editor

Choosing the right medical alert system requires careful consideration of various factors, including equipment options, pricing, customer service, and more. Among the prominent providers in the market, Medical Guardian and MobileHelp are often compared. In this article, we will examine the offerings of both companies and help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs.

Medical Guardian logo
#2 Medical Guardian
8.9 Overall Score
4.4
star star star star star_half
(16,067)
MobileHelp logo
#1 MobileHelp
9.4 Overall Score
4.6
star star star star star_half
(14,585)

Overview

Medical Guardian

Monthly Monitoring Price

$29.95 - $44.95

Equipment Fee

Varies

Activation Fee

None

Contract Length

None

Warranty Length

Lifetime

Maximum Range from Base Station

1,400 ft

Time in Business

19 Years

MobileHelp

$19.95 - $54.95

None

None

None

Lifetime

1,400 ft

18 Years

Ratings

Medical Guardian

Overall Score
8.9 of 10
Review Score
4.4
star star star star star_half
Value for Money
4.3
star star star star star_half
Quality of Product or Service
4.4
star star star star star_half
Company Trustworthiness
4.5
star star star star star_half
Likely to Recommend
8.1 of 10

MobileHelp

9.4 of 10
4.6
star star star star star_half
4.4
star star star star star_half
4.5
star star star star star_half
4.5
star star star star star_half
8.4 of 10

Reviews

Medical Guardian

Number of Reviews
16,067
Review Breakdown
4.4
star star star star star_half
1 star
4%
2 star
2%
3 star
7%
4 star
18%
5 star
69%

MobileHelp

14,585
4.6
star star star star star_half
1 star
2%
2 star
2%
3 star
6%
4 star
15%
5 star
75%

Reviews for Medical Guardian

Helpful Favorable Review

star star star star_border star_border

Juanita

March 19th, 2024

DETAILS

check_circle

Verified Customer

check_circle

Review Source

The wait time for an operator to respond when my mother fell was longer than expected. The call number from medical guardian showed as spam on our cell phones when my mom fell. We finally received a call on a landline from the local 911 dispatch letting us know what was going on with our mother.

Helpful Critical Review

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Steve kelly

March 26th, 2024

DETAILS

The service, when needed was adequate. However, the cancellation was not straightforward and I continued to receive bills two years after the customer (a family member) passed away, despite multiple efforts to cancel including their formal cease and desist submission. When you file their cease and desist, you are not provided with a confirmation number so make sure you take screenshots and document all conversations with their customer service department. Even with multiple attempts to cancel they are still sending me bills and threatening to send to a collection agency!

Reviews for MobileHelp

Helpful Favorable Review

star star star star star

Sarah

April 23rd, 2024

DETAILS

check_circle

Verified Customer

check_circle

Review Source

Have used my fall alert once right after l received my equipment. Worked fine but wait to get to an operator was a little long in my opinion. Cannot tell you how long it was because l didn’t time it. I know when one has fallen and needs help getting up, it seems like a long time. Have has several “ fall alerts” when placing unit on my neck but did the cancel alert.

Helpful Critical Review

star star star_border star_border star_border

Mahipal Ghemawat

March 12th, 2024

DETAILS

check_circle

Verified Customer

check_circle

Review Source

Service is poor! I made a shoulder-high test long back but the result was not communicated for a long time. The package did not include any LOCKBOX. No response about this missing LOCKBOX for weeks even after reminders. Even after repeated reminders, the LOCKBOX was mailed only by GROUND! The LOCKBOX did not fit my door handle but no response from MobileHelp! I had to arrange myself a SHURLOCK to make your LOCKBOX fit in my door handle.

The Final Word

Diverse Product Options and Customization

Medical Guardian offers a broad range of medical alert systems to accommodate various preferences and requirements. Their lineup includes in-home systems, mobile options, and even a smartwatch integration. They also provide customization options, allowing users to tailor the features to their specific needs, such as fall detection, GPS tracking, and medication reminders.

MobileHelp, too, offers a range of systems to cater to different needs, although their product selection may not be as extensive as Medical Guardian's. While customization options are not as prominent with MobileHelp, their offerings still provide essential features for personal safety.

Pricing

Pricing is a critical factor for individuals considering medical alert systems. Both Medical Guardian and MobileHelp offer a range of pricing plans tailored to different needs. MobileHelp's pricing starts at $19.95 per month for their basic plan, while Medical Guardian's entry-level plan begins at $29.95 per month. While MobileHelp may appear cheaper at first glance, it's important to consider the additional features and benefits offered by Medical Guardian, which make it a cost-effective choice in the long run. For example, Medical Guardian has a smartwatch medical alert option, whereas Mobile does not. 

Ultimately, both companies offer extensive packages at affordable rates, but the best company for you will depend on the type of equipment you want and how much you're willing to pay. 

Equipment Options

Medical Guardian and MobileHelp offer a variety of equipment options to cater to different lifestyles and preferences. Both companies provide wearable devices with emergency buttons that can be worn as pendants or wristbands. Both companies offer additional features such as fall detection, which automatically triggers an alert in case of a fall, even if the user is unable to press the button. This feature provides an extra layer of protection and is particularly valuable for individuals at a higher risk of falls.

Customer Reviews

Customer reviews play a crucial role in evaluating the reliability and performance of any product or service. Medical Guardian consistently receives high praise from its customers, with many commending its responsive monitoring center, prompt emergency response, and overall reliability. The company has built a strong reputation for exceptional customer service and has received numerous positive testimonials. While MobileHelp also enjoys a positive reputation and happy customers, Medical Guardian has more reviews to browse, which means more data from customers. 

Monitoring Services

Both Medical Guardian and MobileHelp operate 24/7 monitoring centers staffed with trained professionals who are ready to assist in case of an emergency. Medical Guardian offers an additional layer of protection by having multiple monitoring centers across the United States. This ensures uninterrupted service even in the event of a power outage or natural disaster affecting a particular region. Such a comprehensive monitoring network enhances the reliability and peace of mind for Medical Guardian customers.

Mobile and GPS Capabilities

For individuals who lead an active lifestyle or desire the flexibility to go outside their homes, the availability of mobile and GPS-enabled capabilities is crucial. Medical Guardian offers a portable device called the Mobile Guardian that incorporates cellular and GPS-enabled technology, which helps locate you in the instance of an emergency. While MobileHelp also provides mobile options, Medical Guardian's Mobile Guardian stands out due to its reliable cellular connectivity and accurate GPS-enabled tracking capabilities.

Technological Advancements and Reliability

Both Medical Guardian and MobileHelp leverage advanced technology to ensure a reliable emergency response. Medical Guardian's systems incorporate two-way communication capabilities, enabling direct communication with trained operators at their U.S.-based monitoring centers. Medical Guardian's in-home systems boast extended battery life, ensuring uninterrupted protection even during power outages.

MobileHelp also utilizes cutting-edge technology to facilitate emergency assistance, providing two-way communication with their monitoring centers. 

Customer Service and Support

Medical Guardian is well-regarded for its exceptional customer service. Its team of trained professionals is available to address customer concerns Monday – Friday 9am – 8pm and
Saturday 9am – 5pm. The support site is open 24/7. Lastly, with monitoring centers being open 24/7, all of this support ensures a seamless and satisfactory user experience. Medical Guardian prioritizes personalized and attentive support to meet the needs of their customers.

MobileHelp also offers customer support, but there have been mixed reviews regarding their responsiveness and overall service quality. It is worth noting that customer service experiences may vary, and MobileHelp continues to work on improving its support system.

Conclusion

When considering Medical Guardian and MobileHelp, it is essential to evaluate your personal needs and priorities. Both companies offer reliable medical alert systems with their own set of strengths and weaknesses. Medical Guardian's extensive product lineup, customization options, robust customer service, and transparent pricing make it an attractive choice for individuals seeking a comprehensive and dependable solution.

However, MobileHelp's offerings also provide essential features and functionality, and they continue to work toward an impressive medical alert service. Ultimately, the choice between Medical Guardian and MobileHelp should be based on a thorough assessment of individual preferences and requirements to find the best fit for your specific needs.

Top Choice

MobileHelp Logo
MobileHelp

Other Featured Comparisons