8.1
Overall Score
Average Project Cost: $42 - $77
First American Home Warranty provides affordable home warranty plans starting at $42 per month, offering coverage for essential home systems and appliances. The company has 35+ years of experience and serves 35 states. Service call fees typically start at $75, and while most items have high coverage limits, air conditioning coverage is available only as an add-on for an additional cost.
Author: Best Company Editorial Team
First American Home Warranty is a leading provider of home protection plans designed to give homeowners peace of mind by safeguarding essential home systems and appliances. As part of the First American family, they leverage decades of experience in real estate and title services to back their warranty offerings with strong financial stability and industry understanding. Their mission is to help homeowners reduce unexpected repair costs and enjoy greater predictability in managing home ownership.
At the core of First American Home Warranty’s service offering is a variety of customizable plans that cover a broad range of systems such as: plumbing, HVAC, electrical components and major appliances like refrigerators, washers, and water heaters. Homeowners can choose coverage levels tailored to their needs, benefitting from 24/7 service request submission and partnerships with vetted contractors for professional repairs. The intent is to make service as seamless as possible, limiting the burden on the homeowner during what can be stressful breakdowns.
What distinguishes First American Home Warranty is its integration with real estate and title services, offering bundled options that can streamline the home-buying and selling process. For sellers, adding a home warranty can increase listing appeal; for buyers, it offers protection from day one. Combined with their reputation in adjacent real-estate industries, this positioning allows First American Home Warranty to deliver credibility, trust, and service consistency that many standalone warranty providers seek to match.
One of the key benefits of choosing First American Home Warranty is the wide range of comprehensive coverage plans it provides for homeowners. Unlike some warranty companies that only focus on specific systems or appliances, First American has created plans that cover both critical home systems and everyday appliances. This dual coverage ensures that homeowners aren’t left unprotected when the unexpected happens, whether it’s a heating system breakdown in the middle of winter or a refrigerator failure right before a family gathering.
Homeowners can choose from two primary plan options: the Basic Plan and the Premier Plan. The Basic Plan provides protection for essential household appliances such as refrigerators, ovens, washers, and dryers. The Premier Plan expands that coverage to include vital systems like HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and water heaters. This flexibility allows clients to tailor their warranty to their specific needs and budget, giving them peace of mind without paying for services they don’t require.
Benefits of Comprehensive Coverage:
Another factor that sets First American apart is its add-on options, which allow homeowners to further customize coverage. For example, clients can extend protection to items not typically included in standard plans, such as pool and spa equipment, septic systems, or additional refrigerators. This adaptability is especially beneficial for homeowners with unique property features or high-value appliances.
The value of comprehensive coverage becomes evident when compared to the costs of out-of-pocket repairs or replacements. For example, replacing a central air conditioning unit could cost several thousand dollars, while a new refrigerator may run over a thousand. With First American’s plans, homeowners only pay their plan’s service fee, which is significantly lower than paying full market repair or replacement costs.
In essence, First American Home Warranty’s comprehensive coverage options provide a financial safety net and a convenient solution to the uncertainties of homeownership. By offering flexible, affordable, and customizable plans, the company empowers homeowners to maintain their properties without the stress of unexpected expenses.
One of the standout features of First American Home Warranty is its 24/7 service request availability. Home systems and appliances rarely break down at convenient times, and dealing with a malfunctioning furnace in the middle of the night or a broken refrigerator over a holiday weekend can be incredibly stressful. With First American, homeowners don’t have to wait until business hours to file a claim. The company’s online portal and call center are available around the clock, allowing customers to report problems and request service whenever they occur.
This around-the-clock accessibility offers several advantages. Homeowners gain the peace of mind of knowing that help is just a phone call or online submission away, regardless of the time or day. For busy professionals, this means they can file a claim after work hours. For families, it means an urgent issue like a water heater failure can be addressed quickly without waiting until the next business day.
Benefits of 24/7 Service Requests:
The process itself is designed to be user-friendly and efficient. Once a service request is submitted, First American quickly assigns a licensed and qualified contractor from its network to assess and fix the problem. The homeowner pays only the predetermined service fee, and the rest of the costs are handled by the warranty plan, as long as the repair is covered under the contract.
Another benefit of 24/7 service is how it enhances home value protection. Timely service requests prevent small issues from becoming larger, more expensive problems. For example, a plumbing leak reported right away can often be repaired quickly, avoiding extensive water damage that could cost thousands in repairs.
In today’s fast-paced world, accessibility and responsiveness are key to customer satisfaction. By offering 24/7 service requests, First American ensures that homeowners feel supported whenever issues arise, creating trust and reliability in their warranty coverage. It’s this proactive approach to accessibility that makes the company a top choice for homeowners seeking dependable protection.
One of the most valuable aspects of First American Home Warranty is its extensive vetted contractor network. When homeowners file a claim, the company doesn’t leave them to search for a service provider on their own. Instead, First American connects them with licensed, pre-screened contractors who have been carefully evaluated for quality and professionalism. This saves time, ensures reliability, and eliminates the uncertainty of choosing an unfamiliar technician.
The contractor selection process is designed to prioritize customer satisfaction and quality repairs. Each technician in the network has been thoroughly checked for licenses, certifications, and experience in their trade. From plumbers to electricians to appliance repair specialists, the network includes professionals across a wide range of home systems and appliances.
Benefits of a Vetted Contractor Network:
Another advantage of using First American’s contractor network is consistency. Because the company works with trusted providers regularly, it can maintain higher standards of service and accountability. If a homeowner ever encounters an issue with a contractor’s work, the warranty company can intervene to ensure it’s resolved properly. This layer of accountability isn’t always present when hiring contractors independently.
For homeowners, this translates to a more convenient and stress-free experience. Rather than making calls, scheduling estimates, and comparing prices, they can simply file a claim and trust that a vetted professional will show up ready to resolve the problem. This not only saves time but also prevents costly mistakes from hiring unqualified or inexperienced contractors.
Ultimately, the vetted contractor network adds immense value to the warranty plan by providing homeowners with trustworthy service, consistency, and peace of mind. It ensures that repairs are completed quickly, correctly, and in line with First American’s standards.
Another way First American Home Warranty stands apart is through its affordable costs and flexible coverage options. Home repairs can be expensive, and without a home warranty, a single breakdown could lead to bills in the hundreds or even thousands of dollars. By offering cost-effective plans, First American makes it possible for homeowners to protect their budgets while still getting the coverage they need.
The company provides different levels of coverage, allowing homeowners to choose a plan that matches their needs and financial situation. Whether it’s a basic plan that covers essential appliances and systems or a more comprehensive package that includes additional protections, there are options for every household.
Benefits of Affordable Costs & Flexible Plans:
By spreading out the cost of repairs through manageable monthly or annual payments, homeowners can avoid large, unexpected bills. For example, replacing a broken HVAC system can cost thousands of dollars out of pocket, but with warranty coverage, homeowners only need to pay the set service fee.
Another advantage is that these plans are adjustable over time. As a homeowner’s needs change, perhaps after purchasing new appliances or moving into a larger home, they can adjust their plan for greater protection. This flexibility ensures that the warranty grows with the homeowner’s evolving lifestyle.
The affordability factor also makes First American particularly appealing for first-time buyers or those on a tighter budget. For many, the predictable monthly cost offers peace of mind, knowing they won’t face financial hardship when unexpected home issues occur.
In short, First American’s commitment to offering budget-friendly, flexible coverage ensures that homeowners can find a plan that fits their lifestyle while protecting against costly surprises.
First American Home Warranty is also widely recognized for its integration with real estate transactions. Buying or selling a home is a major milestone, and a home warranty can add significant value to the process for both buyers and sellers. First American has strong partnerships within the real estate industry, making it easy to include warranty coverage as part of the home sale.
For buyers, a warranty offers immediate protection from unexpected repair costs during the stressful and expensive process of purchasing a new home. It ensures that if appliances or systems break shortly after moving in, they won’t face overwhelming bills. For sellers, offering a home warranty as part of the sale can make their property more attractive to potential buyers, providing reassurance that the home is protected.
Benefits of Real Estate Integration:
The company’s experience in real estate makes it easy for agents and homeowners to bundle warranty coverage into the buying or selling process. First American’s team works directly with agents, escrow officers, and homeowners to ensure coverage starts as soon as the home changes hands.
This integration is particularly valuable in competitive housing markets. Homes with warranties often stand out more to buyers, giving sellers an edge while simultaneously providing peace of mind to new homeowners. It’s a win-win situation that strengthens trust on both sides of the transaction.
By weaving warranty coverage seamlessly into real estate, First American helps both buyers and sellers reduce stress, protect investments, and create smoother transactions.
Finally, one of the most compelling reasons to choose First American Home Warranty is its decades of industry experience. As part of the larger First American family, one of the most respected names in real estate and title services, the company brings with it a long history of financial stability, reliability, and customer trust.
Founded in 1984, First American Home Warranty has been serving homeowners for nearly four decades. Over this time, it has refined its services, built an extensive contractor network, and developed coverage options that reflect the real-world needs of homeowners. This experience translates directly into the company’s ability to deliver dependable protection and responsive service.
Advantages of Industry Experience:
In an industry where new providers frequently come and go, longevity matters. A home warranty is only as good as the company behind it, and First American’s long-standing presence ensures that it has the resources, systems, and expertise to handle claims consistently and fairly.
Moreover, the company’s experience has positioned it to anticipate homeowner needs and stay ahead of industry trends. This foresight means that customers benefit not only from today’s solutions but also from a provider that understands where the market is heading.
For homeowners, choosing First American means partnering with a company that has already earned the trust of millions over decades of service. This kind of experience and credibility offers unmatched peace of mind in a marketplace where reliability is everything.
Ready to connect with First American Home Warranty?
Tell us about your project and receive a personalized estimate.
Ready to connect with First American Home Warranty?
Tell us about your project and receive a personalized estimate.
Not every system or appliance in a home is covered. Certain issues like pre-existing conditions, improper installation, lack of maintenance, or cosmetic damage are excluded. Clients should carefully read the contract to understand what is (and isn’t) protected.
Each claim requires a service fee, which can add up if multiple repairs are needed within a short period of time. While this cost is predictable, it’s still an extra expense on top of the annual or monthly premium.
First American assigns contractors from its own vetted network, which means homeowners typically cannot choose their own repair provider. While this ensures quality control, it can sometimes lead to frustration if customers prefer a specific local contractor.
The company decides whether to repair or replace a covered item. In some cases, homeowners may prefer a full replacement, but First American may only authorize a repair if it’s deemed sufficient.
A home warranty should not be confused with homeowners insurance. It covers wear-and-tear repairs and replacements, not damage caused by natural disasters, theft, or accidents.
First American Home Warranty has a mix of customer reviews, with some homeowners praising the company's coverage and affordability, while others express concerns about customer service and slow response times. While many customers appreciate the wide range of covered items and reasonable pricing, some have experienced delays in claim processing and hidden fees that were not clearly communicated upfront.
Choosing First American Home Warranty gives homeowners the confidence that they are backed by a trusted company with decades of experience and a reputation for reliability. With flexible coverage plans, a robust contractor network, and round-the-clock claim service, the company offers protection that eases the burden of unexpected home repairs. This level of security is especially valuable in today’s market, where the costs of maintaining appliances and home systems continue to rise.
Beyond its coverage, First American stands out for its integration with the real estate industry and its commitment to providing affordable, predictable costs. Whether you’re buying a home, selling a property, or simply looking to protect your current investment, the company’s warranties are designed to simplify the process and provide immediate peace of mind. By bridging the gap between homeownership and financial stability, it creates lasting value for its customers.
In the end, First American Home Warranty delivers more than just service—it delivers reliability, convenience, and trust. Homeowners gain not only protection against costly repairs but also the assurance that they’re working with a provider that has stood the test of time. For anyone seeking to reduce stress, save money, and secure their home’s essential systems and appliances, First American remains a dependable choice in the home warranty industry.
Call our recommended rep over at First American Home Warranty below.
1-(866) 908-8515Best Company guarantees your satisfaction if you choose a company that has earned this distinction. If you're not satisfied after 30 days, simply let us know and we'll give you $200. Yes, it's really that simple.
Learn More About Our GuaranteeWe're on a mission to empower consumers to make the best decisions and connect confidently with companies that deserve their business.
© 2025 BestCompany.com LLC - All rights reserved Privacy Policy | Terms | Do Not Sell My Personal Information