Policygenius vs SelectQuote

Kaitlyn Short
Kaitlyn Short | Senior Editor

Policygenius and SelectQuote allow you to compare policies from multiple insurance carriers, which makes it easy to cast a wide net and find good coverage at an affordable price. As you shop you can look for bundling discounts if you buy home and car insurance from the same company. You can also compare your current home insurance policy with others on the market to find a better deal.

Policygenius offers its quote services for more kinds of insurance plans than SelectQuote. Policygenius is also ideal for people researching insurance companies because it offers detailed overviews of insurers.

Policygenius logo verified_user
#10 Policygenius
6.0 Overall Score
5.0
star star star star star
(46)
SelectQuote logo
#54 SelectQuote

Insufficient Reviews

1.0
star star_border star_border star_border star_border
(1)

Overview

Policygenius

A.M. Best Financial Strength Rating

N/A

Demotech Financial Stability Rating

N/A

Customer Service Options

Phone, Live Chat, Email, In-Person

Time in Business

Undisclosed

SelectQuote

N/A

N/A

Phone, Live Chat, Email, In-Person

Undisclosed

Ratings

Policygenius

Overall Score
6.0 of 10
Review Score
5.0
star star star star star
Value for Money
4.9
star star star star star
Quality of Product or Service
4.9
star star star star star
Company Trustworthiness
4.9
star star star star star
Likely to Recommend
9.8 of 10

SelectQuote

0.5 of 10
1.0
star star_border star_border star_border star_border
0.0
star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border
0.0
star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border
0.0
star_border star_border star_border star_border star_border
0.0 of 10

Reviews

Policygenius

Number of Reviews
46
Review Breakdown
5.0
star star star star star
5 star
98%
4 star
2%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
0%

SelectQuote

1
1.0
star star_border star_border star_border star_border
5 star
0%
4 star
0%
3 star
0%
2 star
0%
1 star
100%

Reviews for Policygenius

Helpful Favorable Review

star star star star star

KathyL

July 2nd, 2022

check_circle

Review Source

We needed a homeowners policy to replace our current one. We spoke with several agents locally, who took several days to come back with an undesirable quote in each instance. While initially reluctant to try policygenius, we are now so glad we did! Dan provided prompt, knowledgeable and efficient service. Got us the coverage we need, at a much lower premium, with a reputable, national company! Kudos to Dan B. and Policygenius! We have already recommended you to several friends.

Helpful Critical Review

None Available

Reviews for SelectQuote

Helpful Favorable Review

None Available

Helpful Critical Review

star star_border star_border star_border star_border

Taylor Bjourssen

December 15th, 2021

This company is a bunch of crooks with shady business practices. They are also using robodialers to call people on the Federal Do Not Call list. Don’t say you weren’t warned

The Final Word

With both Policygenius and SelectQuote, you can view quotes from multiple insurers and view bundling deals. You can request a quote online after answering some questions and providing your contact information. If you prefer to work with an insurance agent, both SelectQuote and Policygenius have agents available by phone.

The biggest differences between the companies are time in business, additional insurance policies sold, and resources for insurer research. SelectQuote has been in business longer than Policygenius, so it has more industry experience.

Both companies also help clients with auto and life insurance quotes. SelectQuote also offers Medicare quotes. Policygenius has a much broader selection of insurance products including health insurance, disability insurance, and pet insurance. If you're looking for additional insurance policies beyond auto and life insurance, Policygenius is a nice one-stop shop.

While both companies also offer pages with information on different insurance companies, Policygenius's company overviews are much more in-depth than SelectQuote's company overviews. If you want to research insurers in detail, Policygenius is a great resource.

It's hard to go wrong when choosing between SelectQuote and Policygenius. However, Policygenius gets our recommendation for the breadth of insurance products and detailed company overviews.

Top Choice

Policygenius Logo
Policygenius

Other Featured Comparisons