Wayfair Logo
star star star star star
LAST UPDATED: January 15th, 2022

Wayfair is an online shopping marketplace specializing in furniture and home goods. When it comes to mattresses, you can buy an exclusive Wayfair Sleep brand mattress or shop dozens of these other well-known, and lesser-known, mattress companies:

  • Alwyn Home
  • Best Price Quality
  • Classic Brands
  • CosmoLiving by Cosmopolitan
  • Eco-Lux
  • Hokku Designs
  • Linenspa
  • Lucid
  • Luxury Solutions
  • Madison Home USA
  • Modloft
  • Modway
  • Nora
  • Pure Rest
  • Sealy Beautyrest
  • Serenia Sleep
  • Serta
  • Spinal Solution
  • Stearns & Foster
  • Tempur-Pedic
  • Therapedic
  • The Twillery Co.
  • Wayfair Sleep

Wayfair Sleep offers innerspring, hybrid, memory foam, gel memory foam models and a variety of comfort levels, with easy to sort-through filters and customer reviews. 

In all, Wayfair has over 460 queen size mattresses to choose from, with 160+ options under $500 and 170+ models over $1,000.
At Wayfair, you can buy a mattress, but you can also find a bed, sofa, pillow, bedding, plus curtains, an area rug, and a dresser, and anything else you need at the same time.

Read on for pros and cons as well as Wayfair mattress reviews from real customers.

Top Ranked Companies


The Good

  • Mattress Variety
  • Free Shipping Policy
  • Risk-Free Trial and Return Policy
  • Financing Options

Mattress Variety

Wayfair offers a wide variety of mattress types and brands to help most shoppers find a good night's sleep with the pressure relief they need. Whether you prefer foam, coils, or a combination of the two with a foam comfort layer on top, you can find what you are looking for.

Standard and specialty size options are available. You can even filter through mattresses based on your sleeping position. Back, side, and stomach sleepers can find a comfortable mattress.

Free Shipping Policy

Delivery is free on Wayfair orders over $49.

For some mattresses, you can upgrade your shipping to add on services, but within the United States, orders ship free unless you live in a hard-to-access area. If you do, you are most likely already aware of this.

Even mattresses with one or two-day shipping available ship for free. On top of that, return shipping is free. With many mattress retailers, return shipping only comes with a fee.

This free return policy doesn't apply to every Wayfair purchase, just mattresses.

Risk-Free Trial and Return Policy

Wayfair offers a 100-night sleep trial for mattress purchases. If you are not satisfied within the 100-day policy, contact customer service to initiate an exchange via a refund to store credit.

With Wayfair, shipping is free for orders over $49, so you don’t have to pay a fee to return or re-ship. Mattress shopping, especially shopping for a mattress online, is always easier when you know that you aren’t stuck with a mattress if it turns out that it is not the proper firmness for your body. Buying a mattress is an investment in your personal well-being. No one wants to be stuck tossing and turning on a mattress they can’t stand.

Financing Options

A couple of different financing options are available through Wayfair: The Wayfair Credit Card from Comenity Bank and Affirm loans through Cross River Bank.
The Wayfair Credit Card has several special promotions available for shoppers. First, if you spend over $250 on your first order, you can get $40 off. Additionally, 0 percent APR offers are available and users also earn points towards discounts on future purchases through a cash back program.

Affirm is a payment option that allows you to set up monthly payments at the time of checkout. You will be given an APR between 0–30 percent and know what your monthly payments are before you finish checking out. There are no fees for early payments. Affirm only does a soft credit check.


The Bad

  • Online Only Retailer

Online Only Retailer

Wayfair doesn’t have any local retail locations, except for a few seasonal pop-up locations. They are an online-only marketplace. For mattresses, it makes things a little harder when you can’t actually try-out a mattress, but the 100-night trial makes up for this gamble, helping to overcome any insecurities.


The Bottom Line

Buying a mattress online can sometimes feel like a gamble. At Wayfair, consumers can find several types of mattresses, from memory foam mattresses to innerspring and hybrid models. Shoppers benefit from a wide selection of over 20 brands and a variety of pricing levels. From budget shoppers to luxury lovers, most people will be able to find a comfortable, reasonably priced mattress, whether looking for an innerspring, foam, or hybrid mattress. On top of that, shoppers benefit from a 100-day exchange policy, two financing options, free shipping, and free mattress returns.

Have you ordered a mattress from Wayfair? Let us know about your experience with a quick review below.

Was this content helpful?
thumb_up Yes thumb_down No

Star Rating

star star star star star

3 Reviews

Review Breakdown

5 grade


4 grade


3 grade


2 grade


1 grade


Sentiment Criteria


star star star star star


star star star star star


star star star star star


star star star star star

Filter by:


Sort by:


Review Source

star star star star star

Party0f7 Macomb, MI

My all time favorite mattress is my king size mattress that I ordered from Wayfair two years ago. The shipping was fast, mattress was well packaged, needed to “grow” for two days once opened, and then could be put on my bed frame. The quality will ensure it lasts a long time.

2 years ago


Review Source

star star star star star

Jmarsh Macomb, MI

I love my mattress from Wayfair! It is a king size memory foam and it’s the most comfortable mattress I have ever purchased. Shipping was quick and the price was affordable.

2 years ago


Review Source

star star star star star

Greg Service jr Belleville, IL

Love the pillow top mattress I got. It is one if the best mattresses I've had. Nothing to complain about.

2 years ago