Rest Home or Medical Alert System: The Better Use of Money


Facebook Tweet mail
blog post author image
Written by Aaron Hall | Last Updated February 24th, 2020
Aaron N. Hall is a Content Management Specialist for Best Company and specializes in the home security and medical alert system industries. He would tell you that he’s probably taking pictures, writing music, or working on his next novel while out of the office, but he’s actually just watching Parks and Rec.

rest home vs medical alert

The older you get, the more likely you'll need someone to take care of you. This presents a slew of different challenges, even financial complications. You might ask yourself any number of questions: "Should I pay to stay in an assisted living home?" "What about my independence?" "What about a medical alert system?" "What are the benefits of that?" If you're not sure which option is right for you, here are a few important factors to consider:

Which Option Is More Cost Effective?

According to our research at, top-rated medical alert companies typically charge a maximum of approximately $50/month for their most expensive programs. Some companies will occasionally charge an activation fee or equipment fee, but top-rated companies such as Medical Guardian and MobileHelp do away with those to give customers a consistent and affordable price.

In comparison, a nursing home is much more expensive. According to a study by MetLife in 2012, the average cost of a private room within a nursing home was $248/day! Now, there are less expensive options like assisted living and adult day care. According to similar studies, assisted living costs an average of $3,022/month and adult day care can be up to $100/day. It doesn't take a master's degree in mathematics to conclude that a medical alert system is more cost effective, but let's quantify this in order to put it in perspective. We've broken the comparison down for you in the following infographic:

Elderly care cost comparison infographic

When you compare the two programs, the obvious choice regarding cost is a medical alert system.

But Is It the Best Choice for Me?

That depends. Just because a medical alert system is far less expensive doesn't mean that it's the ideal choice for everyone. Nursing homes and assisted living homes will usually offer additional services such as housekeeping, meal prep, recreational activities, and on-site medical assistance. You won't get any of that from a medical alert system, except for a quick, on-hand response tool for medical emergencies. A medical alert system is recommended for an individual that still has the capacity to live independently.

Ultimately, this is up to you. Before you make a final decision, it's important to assess your health and independence needs, and also to shop around.

The Top Medical Alert Systems Companies

company logo
#1 Medical Guardian chevron_right
9.5 Overall Score
company logo
#2 MobileHelp chevron_right
9.4 Overall Score
company logo
#3 One Call Alert chevron_right
7.8 Overall Score

Related Articles

Best Medical Alert Companies of 2019

August 09, 2019

Guest Post by Ethan Lichtenberg Humans crave independence. To be able to operate your own life strictly on your own is ...

Read More
Medical Guardian Named 2019 Consumer’s Choice Award Recipi...

January 07, 2019

Pleasant Grove, UT - January 7, 2019 - Medical Guardian has been named the 2019 Consumer's Choice Award recipient in th...

Read More
Do You Need a Medical Alert System? [Quiz]

August 08, 2018

Injuries from falls are the leading cause of death among seniors 65 and older. Thankfully, industry leaders such as Medi...

Read More