Sorted By:
#1
Visit Site
  • ~$78.10/month
  • Services all 50 states
  • Track claims online

3 REAL REVIEWS  |  7 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
7.8
User Score
3.0
#1

Geico Auto Insurance

7.8

our score

3.0

user score

REVIEWS

7 MONTHSAGO

#2
Visit Site
  • Powered by Allstate
  • $129–$145/month
  • Nationwide coverage

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  7 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
7.7
#2

Esurance Auto Insurance

7.7

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

7 MONTHSAGO

#3
Visit Site
  • Available in 43 states
  • File claims online
  • $92 per month

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  7 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
7.6
#3

Travelers

7.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

7 MONTHSAGO

#4
Visit Site
  • All 50 states coverage
  • Mobile app available
  • ~$112/month

3 REAL REVIEWS  |  7 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
7.2
User Score
3.3
#4

Allstate Auto Insurance

7.2

our score

3.3

user score

REVIEWS

7 MONTHSAGO

#5
Visit Site
  • $65–$202/month
  • 49 states coverage
  • Auto discounts

1 REAL REVIEW  |  6 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
7.0
User Score
9.0
#5

Progressive Auto Insurance

7.0

our score

9.0

user score

1 REVIEW

6 MONTHSAGO

#6
Visit Site
  • ~$117/month
  • Nationwide availability
  • No online filing

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  6 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
6.9
#6

Safeco Auto Insurance

6.9

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

6 MONTHSAGO

#7
Visit Site
  • $110–$129/month
  • Submit claims online
  • Limited availability

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  6 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
6.8
#8
Visit Site
  • No online tracking
  • Available in all 50 states + internationally
  • $95.50 per month

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  6 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
6.6
#8

MetLife

6.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

6 MONTHSAGO

#9
Visit Site
  • ~$132.17/month
  • Nationwide coverage
  • File claims online

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  6 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
6.5
#9

Farmers Auto Insurance

6.5

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

6 MONTHSAGO

#10
Visit Site
  • $151/month
  • 49-state coverage
  • Discount programs available

1 REAL REVIEW  |  11 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
6.2
User Score
9.0
#10

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance

6.2

our score

9.0

user score

1 REVIEW

11 MONTHSAGO

#11
Visit Site
  • $101.38/month Average Price
  • Coverage in 11 States
  • File/track claims online

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  11 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
6.2
#11

Erie Insurance

6.2

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

11 MONTHSAGO

#12
Visit Site
  • Available in every state
  • Available for people 50+
  • Undisclosed pricing

1 REAL REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.9
User Score
0.0
#12

AARP

5.9

our score

0.0

user score

1 REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#13
Visit Site
  • Available in 49 states
  • Multiple discounts available
  • $132/month

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.9
#13

21st Century Insurance

5.9

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#14
Visit Site
  • $112–$151/month
  • Mobile app
  • 46-state coverage

1 REAL REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.8
User Score
0.0
#14

Nationwide Auto Insurance

5.8

our score

0.0

user score

1 REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#15
Visit Site
  • ~$121/month
  • Serves CA, UT, and NV
  • File/track claims online

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.8
#15

AAA

5.8

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#16
Visit Site
  • Services for military members and families
  • Unknown price range
  • All 50 states serviced

3 REAL REVIEWS  |  1 WEEKAGO

Our Score
5.7
User Score
10
#16

USAA Auto Insurance

5.7

our score

10

user score

REVIEWS

1 WEEKAGO

#17
Visit Site
  • $184–$230/month
  • Services to Canada
  • Mobile App

1 REAL REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.7
User Score
0.0
#17

State Farm Auto Insurance

5.7

our score

0.0

user score

1 REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#18
Visit Site
  • Low/Competitive Rates
  • No Online Management
  • Available in 11 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.7
#19
Visit Site
  • Covers All Basic Auto Insurance Needs
  • Complete Online Management
  • Available in an Unknown Number of States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.7
#19

Freedom National

5.7

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#20
Visit Site
  • Available in all states except Hawaii
  • Multiple discounts available
  • $237/month

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.6
#20

Amica

5.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#21
Visit Site
  • Online Managment
  • Variety of Insurance Options
  • Available in 26 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.2
#21

Western National

5.2

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#22
Visit Site
  • No online claims
  • Only available in select states
  • $129-145 per month

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  1 YEARAGO

Our Score
5.1
#22

SafeAuto

5.1

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

1 YEARAGO

#23
Visit Site
  • Coverage in 26 states
  • No price range given
  • No online claims

1 REAL REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.8
User Score
10
#23

Auto-Owners.com

4.8

our score

10

user score

1 REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#24
Visit Site
  • Policy Management Online
  • Coverage and Enhancements Provided
  • Available in 26 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.6
#24

Kemper Direct

4.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#25
Visit Site
  • Various Forms of Insurance Available
  • Discounts Provided Upon Qualification
  • Available in 4 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.6
#25

Plymouth Rock

4.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#26
Visit Site
  • Insurance for High-Risk Drivers Provided
  • Discounted Rates For Eligible Drivers
  • Available in 22 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.6
#26

Titan Insurance

4.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#27
Visit Site
  • $102–$118/month
  • Serves 47 states
  • Poor coverage features

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.4
#27

The General

4.4

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#28
Visit Site
  • Coverage in 12/ states
  • No price range available
  • No online claims tracking

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.3
#28

Alfa

4.3

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#29
Visit Site
  • Available in 34 states
  • Unknown monthly fees
  • No online claims tracking

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.3
#29

Allied

4.3

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#30
Visit Site
  • Undisclosed pricing
  • Coverage in 8 states
  • Online file/track claims options

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
4.0
#30

Farm Bureau Financial Services

4.0

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#31
Visit Site
  • Customized Coverage
  • Policy Discounts May Apply
  • Available Worldwide

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
3.9
#31

Chubb

3.9

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#32
Visit Site
  • Undisclosed pricing
  • File claims online
  • Available in 11 states

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
3.8
#32

Mercury Insurance

3.8

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#33
Visit Site
  • Discounts Available
  • Auto and Motorcycle Coverage
  • Available in 43 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
3.7
#33

Dairyland

3.7

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#34
Visit Site
  • Unavailable pricing and coverage details
  • Available in all 50 states
  • File claims online

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
3.6
#34

Infinity

3.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#35
Visit Site
  • Rates Vary on Driver
  • Standard Auto Insurance Coverage
  • Available in 3 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
3.6
#35

Sun Coast

3.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#36
Visit Site
  • Bundle Insurance Policies for Savings
  • Wide Range of Insurance Coverage
  • Available in 43 States

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
3.5
#36

Foremost Insurance Group

3.5

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#37
Visit Site
  • Availability undisclosed
  • Pricing undisclosed
  • No online claims

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
2.3
#37

AIG

2.3

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#38
Visit Site
  • Unknown Coverage Options
  • Auto and Flood Insurance Available
  • Available in 1 State

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
2.0
#38

Mendota Insurance

2.0

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO

#39
Visit Site
  • No price range available
  • Coverage in 12 states
  • No online claims filing

ADD YOUR REVIEW  |  4 MONTHSAGO

Our Score
1.6
#39

Loya Insurance Group

1.6

our score

--

user score

ADD REVIEW

4 MONTHSAGO